Is there a need to break in used boots?

[xray328]

Kids both got used Corcoran boots off eBay.  They've obviously been worn/broken in already but do they need to do the break in process again since it's a different foot in the boot?

I'm seeing people suggest filling them with water so they are dripping wet then wearing them until they dry?  Is that still the best way?

[SarDragon]

It works, but it's really hard on the boots and the feet in them.

[Holding Pattern]

Kids both got used Corcoran boots off eBay.  They've obviously been worn/broken in already but do they need to do the break in process again since it's a different foot in the boot?

I'm seeing people suggest filling them with water so they are dripping wet then wearing them until they dry?  Is that still the best way?

That is still the worst way. Buy some leather conditioner and use that on the boots. Wear them at home first, then work up to heavier use. Water will warp and crack the leather, and probably crack your skin on your feet as well.

Just like you would use moisturizer on your feet, leather conditioner is what you'll use to make the leather more supple to conform to new feet.

[Holding Pattern]

http://us.magnumboots.com/resources/boot-cleaning-and-care

This site appears to have really solid data on boot care.

[A.Member]

FWIW, if the plan is to wear them anywhere for any meaningful amount of time, I'd rather buy a *new* set of the cheap $40-$50 knockoffs than buy a *used* set of Corcorans/insert higher end boot manufacturer here.  Boots broken in to someone else's foot are not good, especially if you're going to be in them an extended period of time (long weekend/week).