Cadet Abuses Power

[Luis R. Ramos]

CAPR 52-10, for starters.

See http://www.capmembers.com/media/cms/R052_010_C5B73B2B78712.pdf Section 1.2. e.

[MSG Mac]

Time for the cadet to read the regulations regarding Hazing and Harrassment.

Where can I find those?

E Services I believe it's CAPR 52-10

[MajorM]

Talk to your Deputy Commander for Cadets.  Why your first instinct is to come to Cap-talk and not your senior member chain of command makes me think there is much more to the story.

[Storm Chaser]

^ Not necessarily. Some new/junior cadets don't know that they can go directly to the deputy commander for cadets or squadron commander if they have a problem that goes beyond what the cadet leadership can or should have to deal with.

While the chain of command (CoC) is designed to address issues at the lowest level possible, it takes some experience to know which level is the appropriate one to start with. Many new members also don't understand that the way the CoC works is that if one person in the chain can't or won't help you, you can go to the next up the chain to seek a resolution.

Finally, issues regarding abuse or safety violations must be addressed right away and should be handled by the senior CoC, not the cadet CoC.

[EMT-83]

We've seen many times where new cadets are afraid to approach senior members with problems such as these. Following the chain of command doesn't mean a hard stop when a 13 year-old NCO is being a jerk.

Hey kids, us old folks don't bite! We're real people that you can talk to without the world coming to an end.

[The CyBorg is destroyed]

The Safety Officer in me does not at all like the way in which this cadet was not allowed to hydrate.

I remember during BMT aeons ago, one of the first (printable) words I learnt out of my MTI was "HYDRATE!"  You kept that canteen with you and full and ready to hydrate.

I was running flight line safety at an airshow about 15 years ago.  It was a hot summer day.  There was a cadet who was visibly sweating.  He had a bottle of water with him so I told him to hydrate.  He said "I don't really feel the need, Lieutenant."  I said, "I don't care what you feel.  It's hot, you're sweating and I'm not having you pass out on me.  Drink your water."

If I had been at this squadron, and in my old post as Safety Officer, both the CC and I would have had a few words with this cadet NCO.  Thoroughly unacceptable.

[MajorM]

They don't know to go to their senior members, but they do know to go to CAP-Talk?  Sorry.. Something still doesn't line up for me.  There's a part of the story we're not getting.

[LSThiker]

They don't know to go to their senior members, but they do know to go to CAP-Talk?  Sorry.. Something still doesn't line up for me.  There's a part of the story we're not getting.

While there may be more to the story, but going to the internet to ask a question is not an uncommon behavior of today's youth.  They have grown up with access to the internet and are comfortable with it.  A youth can feel "safer" by asking a question to a group of anonymous people and stay relatively "anonymous" as well, even if they post their name.  If they feel they are being judged, it is easier to simply walk away from that internet site and the problem will simply disappear as opposed to real life where it is person-to-person contact.

The same reaction is seen in numerous examples with today's youth.  If they get bullied in school, they turn to the internet as opposed to a teacher or parents.  They have an embarrassing medical question, they do not ask their parents or a school nurse, they turn to the internet.  They feel stressed, they do not ask parents, teachers, clergy, instead they ask the internet.  Children that become pregnant will turn to the internet before telling their parents or a medical doctor.  Children with depression will go to the internet before asking parents, medical workers, friends, or a school counselor.     

At the same, the behavior is seen in adults as well.  Not always, but it is becoming more common as people age.  For example, you will see new parents turn to parenting websites instead of asking their own parents, doctors, or other trusted persons.  Instead of asking their own fathers or friends, some men will turn to the internet to look up car issues or handyman problems.  Lesbians, gays, transgender (LBGT) usually come out first on the internet before ever telling their parents or friends.  The same with atheists or other people looking to switch religions.  Some rape victims will turn to the internet before ever going to the police, parents, or medical workers.   

People of all ages feel embarrassed and/or do not want to feel the social pressure by asking another person or bringing up an issue.  When they turn to the internet, you do not always get that same feeling.

[Brit_in_CAP]

^   Well stated by LSTHiker.  The web gives a feeling of anonymity that is all too false.  Nevertheless...it is the first place a lot of people go so that they feel more informed when they talk to someone in person.

[Reader5567]

They don't know to go to their senior members, but they do know to go to CAP-Talk?  Sorry.. Something still doesn't line up for me.  There's a part of the story we're not getting.

While there may be more to the story, but going to the internet to ask a question is not an uncommon behavior of today's youth.  They have grown up with access to the internet and are comfortable with it.  A youth can feel "safer" by asking a question to a group of anonymous people and stay relatively "anonymous" as well, even if they post their name.  If they feel they are being judged, it is easier to simply walk away from that internet site and the problem will simply disappear as opposed to real life where it is person-to-person contact.

The same reaction is seen in numerous examples with today's youth.  If they get bullied in school, they turn to the internet as opposed to a teacher or parents.  They have an embarrassing medical question, they do not ask their parents or a school nurse, they turn to the internet.  They feel stressed, they do not ask parents, teachers, clergy, instead they ask the internet.  Children that become pregnant will turn to the internet before telling their parents or a medical doctor.  Children with depression will go to the internet before asking parents, medical workers, friends, or a school counselor.     

At the same, the behavior is seen in adults as well.  Not always, but it is becoming more common as people age.  For example, you will see new parents turn to parenting websites instead of asking their own parents, doctors, or other trusted persons.  Instead of asking their own fathers or friends, some men will turn to the internet to look up car issues or handyman problems.  Lesbians, gays, transgender (LBGT) usually come out first on the internet before ever telling their parents or friends.  The same with atheists or other people looking to switch religions.  Some rape victims will turn to the internet before ever going to the police, parents, or medical workers.   

People of all ages feel embarrassed and/or do not want to feel the social pressure by asking another person or bringing up an issue.  When they turn to the internet, you do not always get that same feeling.

I would like to clarify, I did speak to a senior member, and the situation was handled. I should have been clearer in my original post. I was looking for advice on how to handle it on my own should it happen again. Thank you all for your help.

[MajorM]

Well good for you then.. And you already have your answer.  Everyone has a boss, and when you have an issue with someone you find their boss and speak your truth.

As far as LSThinker... I realize going to the internet is common, but that doesn't make it right, smart, or appropriate.  Nor does it really solve much.  If I need to figure out how to install a toilet, yes, I can find a good answer with video on the internet.  If I need a solution to an immediate human interaction problem... The internet is not the place, particularly when there is an established system to redress concerns.  I work closely with cadets and see it, you're correct, but we should guide them back to proper channels.  When in the workplace and they use the internet as their sounding board they will have real problems.

The internet, like any tool, is good when used for the appropriate task.  Some answers here were spot on "go to your chain".  Others espoused all types of imagined transgressions and recommendations.  Thus is the nature of the internet.

But in general real problems with real people and best addressed by really talking.  Not crowd-sourcing from some yahoos (myself included) on the internet.

[MajorM]

Hmmm that first sentence came off sounding flippant... I genuinely mean well done for using your chain of command... That's how it is supposed to work. Good job!

[LSThiker]

I realize going to the internet is common, but that doesn't make it right, smart, or appropriate. 

Not arguing that.  Sometimes it is useful to go to the internet, others not.  However, to assume that there is more to the story because a person asks a question on the internet is not a logical conclusion, especially when it is a common practice.

[Eclipse]

I would like to clarify, I did speak to a senior member, and the situation was handled. I should have been clearer in my original post. I was looking for advice on how to handle it on my own should it happen again. Thank you all for your help.

If you spoke to him and it was handled before posting here, then this makes no sense.

It's one thing to abuse authority that is given..."I'm higher rank than you, therefore you must do as I say."  From a 13-year old cadet, that's simply a lack of experience and understanding of leadership.  That comes with time and maturity.  We've all been through it.

What you're talking about is hazing and bullying, which isn't acceptable in CAP from anyone under any circumstances.  Your best course of action is to tell a senior member about it in your squadron, preferably your Deputy Commander of Cadets.

Thanks a lot. I will report him on Thursday.

[MajorM]

There is always more to the story.  Short of having a video of the event (and even that is not foolproof) the full story is never possible to provide.  If nothing else, author's bias will be present.  The mass of variables in human interaction makes sourcing an answer on a human problem via the internet an exercise in futility.  My experience authors with "hear my problem" are either looking for ammo to confront a real or imagined confrontation with a supervisor or are seeking affirmation of their world view to justify whatever it is they wish to do next.

And just to point out... There was more to the story, though the veracity of that is questionable as Eclipse points out.